Back to All comparisons

Comparison · Facts checked November 14, 2026

Answering service, AI receptionist or hiring someone: which is right for a trade company?

Every trade company has the same problem: the phone rings while everyone is on a job, and the caller tries the next shop. There are four common ways to fix it. Here's what each one costs and does, including where ours isn't the best fit.

  • 48%of calls to home service companies aren't answered by a person (Invoca, 2026)
  • Under 3%of callers sent to voicemail actually leave a message (Invoca, 2024)
  • $3,170a month in wages for one full-time receptionist at median pay
  • 40 of 168hours a week one full-time person can cover

At a glance

  • Monthly cost

    On Call Pal
    Free for 60 days, then one flat price
    Hire a receptionist
    About $3,170 in wages
    Answering service
    Per minute or per call
    Self-serve AI receptionist
    Often $20 to $300
  • Calls included

    On Call Pal
    Yes: Unlimited
    Hire a receptionist
    Partly: One at a time
    Answering service
    Partly: You pay for every call or minute
    Self-serve AI receptionist
    Partly: Varies; many have limits
  • Hours covered

    On Call Pal
    Yes: Every hour, or the calls you choose
    Hire a receptionist
    No: About 40 of 168 a week
    Answering service
    Yes: Usually every hour
    Self-serve AI receptionist
    Yes: Every hour
  • Books the job

    On Call Pal
    Yes: Yes, into Google Calendar or Jobber
    Hire a receptionist
    Yes: Yes
    Answering service
    Partly: Usually takes a message
    Self-serve AI receptionist
    Partly: Varies; often a message or a link
  • Emergencies

    On Call Pal
    Yes: Safety steps, then your on-call tech
    Hire a receptionist
    Partly: If trained and on shift
    Answering service
    Partly: Passed on, following your script
    Self-serve AI receptionist
    Partly: Varies; usually to one phone
  • Setup

    On Call Pal
    Yes: Done for you on one call
    Hire a receptionist
    Partly: Hire, train, cover time off
    Answering service
    Partly: You write the script
    Self-serve AI receptionist
    Partly: You set it up yourself

Yes: YesPartly: Partly or it dependsNo: No, or not yet

What it costs to have a person answer every hour

  • Covering all 168 hours of the week with people takes more than four full-time receptionists: about $13,300 a month in wages alone at the median pay, before payroll taxes, benefits and managing the schedule.
  • That's why most shops end up with someone in the office during the day and voicemail the rest of the time. Those after-hours calls are often the urgent, well-paid ones.

When each one makes sense

  • Hire someone if you need a person in the office anyway: greeting walk-ins, handling invoices, chasing payments. Pair them with something for nights and weekends.
  • An answering service makes sense if you mostly want a message taken and you'll call people back yourself.
  • A self-serve AI receptionist makes sense if price matters most and you're comfortable setting it up and adjusting it yourself.
  • On Call Pal makes sense if you want the job booked on the call, emergencies handled the way your trade handles them, and someone else to set it up and look after it.
Every detail, row by rowThe full wording behind the table, from each company's own site.

Cost

On Call Pal
Free for 60 days on your real calls. After that, one flat monthly price, usually less than one or two extra jobs a month.
Hire a receptionist
About $3,170 a month in wages for one full-time person at the median receptionist pay of $18.27 an hour, before payroll taxes and benefits.
Answering service
Usually charged per minute or per call. Prices vary a lot by provider.
Self-serve AI receptionist
Often $20 to $300 a month, depending on the plan and how many calls or minutes.

Calls included

On Call Pal
Unlimited. One flat monthly price with no per-call or per-minute charges, so a busy month never brings a surprise bill.
Hire a receptionist
As many as one person can take, one at a time. A second call while they're on the phone goes to voicemail.
Answering service
You pay for every call or minute, so a busy month costs more.
Self-serve AI receptionist
Varies. Some are unlimited; many charge per call or per conversation past a monthly limit.

Hours covered

On Call Pal
Every hour, or only the calls you choose: all of them, the ones you miss, or after hours.
Hire a receptionist
About 40 of the week's 168 hours. Nights, weekends and lunch breaks still go to voicemail unless you hire more people.
Answering service
Usually every hour.
Self-serve AI receptionist
Every hour.

Books the job

On Call Pal
Books the job into a real open time in Google Calendar or Jobber while the customer is on the phone, and can give it to a free tech who does that kind of work.
Hire a receptionist
Yes, and they learn your business over time.
Answering service
Usually takes a message and passes it on. Some can book for an extra charge.
Self-serve AI receptionist
Varies. Many take a message or text the caller a booking link; some book directly.

Emergencies

On Call Pal
Knows the emergencies in your trade (gas smell, burst pipe, sparking panel, no heat in the cold). Safety steps first, then it alerts whoever is on call that night and puts the caller straight through.
Hire a receptionist
Yes, if they're trained and on shift.
Answering service
Can pass urgent calls on, following a script you give them.
Self-serve AI receptionist
Varies. Most let you send urgent calls or alerts to one phone.

Setup

On Call Pal
We set it up for you on one call: hours, services, service area, prices you're happy to quote and who's on call. We test it with you and change anything you ask later.
Hire a receptionist
Hiring and training, then covering sick days and vacations.
Answering service
Fill in a script and call instructions.
Self-serve AI receptionist
You set it up yourself, often in minutes.

Questions

Is an AI receptionist cheaper than hiring a receptionist?

Yes, by a lot. A full-time receptionist at the median pay of $18.27 an hour costs about $3,170 a month in wages and covers about 40 hours a week. An AI receptionist answers all 168 hours for a fraction of that. A person still makes sense if you need someone in the office for other work.

Is an answering service or an AI receptionist better for a plumber or HVAC company?

It depends on what you want from the call. A traditional answering service usually takes a message for you to call back. A good AI receptionist books the job into your schedule while the customer is on the phone, which matters because callers who don't get booked often call the next company.

Do customers mind talking to an AI receptionist?

What callers care about is that someone picked up, understood the problem and booked them in. On Call Pal tells callers it's a virtual assistant, and every call is recorded with a transcript so you can hear exactly how it went.

Sources

Facts about Hire a receptionist, Answering service, Self-serve AI receptionist come from the pages below, checked on November 14, 2026. Prices and features change, so check their site before you decide, and tell us if anything here is out of date and we'll fix it.